Gene Therapy for ALS — Where Are We Now?
by Paul Muhlrad
Gene therapy, a high-tech approach that aims to fight diseases with
genes rather than drugs, may one day become the chosen means for treating
many medical disorders. Scientists seeking a gene therapy approach to
ALS face some formidable hurdles but are making progress.
Ten percent of all those who have ALS have a familial (inherited) form.
In the early 1990s, a team of researchers, with support from MDA, discovered
that many of those with familial ALS have a mutation in a gene called SOD1 (see “Denise Figlewicz”).
Even though scientists still haven’t figured out exactly how
SOD1 mutations cause ALS, they have exploited this finding to create
a powerful tool in their quest toward a treatment for both familial
and sporadic ALS: the SOD1 mutant mouse model of ALS.
These custom-designed mice enable scientists to study ALS and test
potential treatments in rodent models before attempting risky experiments
on humans.
Pediatric neurologist Gyula Acsadi, an MDA research grantee at Wayne
State University in Detroit and co-director of the MDA clinic at Children’s
Hospital of Michigan, is one of a small army of researchers using SOD1
mutant mice to develop a gene therapy for ALS.
In 2002, Acsadi and colleagues tested whether they could treat SOD1
mice by introducing a therapeutic gene into them. The gene they chose
carries instructions for a protein called GDNF (glial-cell-derived
neurotrophic factor).
The Possibilities of Neurotrophic Factors
GDNF and other neurotrophic factor proteins normally function in the
body to nourish nerve cells and protect them from natural processes
that can damage or kill them. Researchers have long proposed that supplying
extra neurotrophic factors to people with ALS might help their motor
neurons (muscle-controlling nerve cells) resist a progressive degenerative
process. But unfortunately, for more than a decade, clinical trials
in which people with ALS have been injected with neurotrophic factors
have failed to demonstrate any significant benefit.
Acsadi counters that those trials may have been flawed. “Nobody
really checked whether those proteins were getting to the neurons or
getting close by, or how they would cause any therapeutic effect. They
don’t even stay in the blood for more than five or 10 minutes
because the body degrades them so rapidly.”
If GDNF genes were introduced into the diseased tissues, Acsadi
reasoned, they would continue to produce the protective neurotrophic
factors, even as the proteins were degraded, and they’d stand
a better chance of performing their nurturing role.
Testing Theories
Acsadi tested his notion by inserting GDNF genes into altered virus
particles and injecting the muscles of SOD1 mice with the genetically
engineered, gene-carrying viruses. As predicted, the treatment delayed
the onset of disease in the mice, extending their lives by two weeks
(12 percent) compared to their untreated littermates. The treatment
diminished — and in some cases even reversed — their nerve
and muscle degeneration.
 |
|
Treating Mice
With Genes
In 2002, Acsadi’s group inserted genes for GDNF into ALS-affected
mice. The genes, they believe, traveled up the axons (fibers)
of nerve cells into the nerve cell bodies. Similar experiments
have been conducted with the neurotrophic factors IGF1 and VEGF.
|
After Acsadi’s group published its results, neurobiologist Fred
Gage at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies in San Diego and colleagues
performed similar experiments to test IGF1 (insulin-like growth factor
1), announcing their findings in 2003. Using an adeno-associated
virus (AAV) as a delivery vehicle (vector), Gage’s team found
IGF1 genes to be twice as effective as GDNF, extending the lives of
SOD1 mice by as much as a month. (Researchers caution that the life
span extensions of mice can’t be extrapolated directly to humans.)
Acsadi is currently refining his experiments, using both GDNF and IGF1,
and is developing a virus-free gene delivery system, which he hopes
will be even more effective than the current virus-based treatments.
Clues From VEGF
A collaboration between MDA grantee Peter Carmeliet at the University
of Leuven and the Flanders Interuniversity Institute for Biotechnology,
in Belgium, and British biopharmaceutical company Oxford BioMedica,
also appears headed toward that goal, focusing on a third protein, VEGF
(vascular endothelial growth factor). (Oxford Biomedica is now developing
a patented VEGF gene therapy compound, under the name MoNuDin.)
Like GDNF and IGF1, VEGF promotes the growth and health of certain
tissue types in the body. Until recently, scientists thought VEGF’s
effects were restricted to the cells that form blood vessels.
Then, in 2001, while conducting experiments on blood vessel growth
in mice by removing a portion of their VEGF genes, Carmeliet’s
group noticed that some of the mice displayed muscle and nerve problems
reminiscent of ALS. The researchers followed up on those observations
and confirmed that VEGF, like GDNF and IGF1, is indeed critical for
maintaining healthy nerve cells.
Suspecting that low VEGF levels in the body might contribute to causing
ALS, Carmeliet examined VEGF genes in people with ALS and found that
certain variations in the gene that give rise to low VEGF protein levels
are more prevalent in ALS patients than they are in people without the
disease.
So, if insufficient levels of VEGF lead to ALS, he reasoned, perhaps
supplying the body with extra VEGF could slow or even turn back the
ravages of the disease.
Last year Carmeliet’s group and Oxford BioMedica tested VEGF
gene therapy in SOD1 mice, and saw dramatic results.In addition to offering
a clear improvement in nerve and muscle function, VEGF extended the
lives of the mice by about 30 percent. The gene therapy was effective
even when administered after the mice began showing signs of neuromuscular
decline.
Unfortunately, obstacles to gene therapy for humans with ALS —
technical, financial and regulatory — still exist, despite major
advances in the basic science.
“The difficulty,” says Gyula Acsadi, “is how to move
forward from animal experiments to human trials.”
Back to top

Can't Get In? Work It Out
by Christina Medvescek
No ramps. No grab bars. No elevators. No access. No fair.
Although the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) has been federal
law since 1990, in many places accessibility still isn’t a reality.
There are no “ADA police” searching for accessibility violations.
Instead, accessibility is enforced through private lawsuits —
a lengthy and expensive process — or through complaints filed
with the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ).
Each year, approximately 300 DOJ complaints are settled relatively
quickly and inexpensively through the ADA Mediation Program, a free
service with a 75 percent success rate in reaching agreements.
Win-Win Agreements
Mediation is a voluntary process in which the complainant (i.e., person
with a disability) and respondent (i.e., business owner) sit down in
a convenient, accessible location with a neutral, non-judging third
party to discuss the situation and see if they can reach a mutually
satisfying solution. An attorney isn’t required, although either
party may have one present.
Agreements are binding, and the case isn’t formally settled until
the solution has been implemented. If no agreement is reached, the complainant
or DOJ may pursue other legal remedies.
Examples of ADA mediation settlements include:
- An amphitheater at a Texas amusement park that only provided accessible
seating with poor lines of sight agreed to restructure so accessible
seats are available throughout the theater.
- A small flower shop in Pennsylvania that couldn’t easily be
made wheelchair accessible agreed to install a call bell at the door
and provide curb or home service for customers with disabilities.
- A large craft store in Colorado that had aisles blocked by merchandise
and heavy entrance doors agreed to clear the aisles and install automatic
doors.
- A Texas hotel that charged a higher rate for the only room with
a roll-in shower because it also contained a hot tub changed its policy
to charge regular room rates to guests with disabilities.
How to File
To discover whether an architectural barrier or organizational policy
violates the ADA, call the ADA Hotline, (800) 514-0301,
or the Disability Business Technical Assistance Center (DBTAC) at (800)
949-4232. Information also is available online at the DOJ Web
site, www.usdoj.gov/crt/ada/mediate.htm,
or the DBTAC site, www.adata.org/centers.htm.
To file an access complaint, write the U.S. Department of Justice,
Civil Rights Division, 950 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Disability Rights Section
– NYAV, Washington, DC 20530. Although DOJ automatically
refers appropriate cases to mediation, you may speed up the process
a little by writing “mediation” on your complaint.
One warning: Complainants who refuse to mediate may have their complaints
closed without a DOJ investigation. However, if the respondent refuses
to mediate, DOJ automatically institutes a formal investigation.
Back to top

Kids and ALS
by Christopher and Reda Rice
We’re the parents of three children, ages 8, 6 and 5. Chris has
had ALS for three years, and the biggest challenge for us is explaining
this disease to our kids. We want to protect their minds and hearts.
We want to keep them from being fearful or angry.
How? After much thought, we do what many others do… try to balance the reality of ALS with hope:
B — Believe in
yourself …. Trust yourself when it comes to speaking with them
and reading their emotions. Trust your instinct to get help when needed
and listen to others in your child’s life. In my family, our children
have opened up to their friends’ parents or teachers. Communication
with the other people in the lives of our children allows us insight
into their thoughts about Chris’ ALS.
A — Accept before
you expect your children to accept. For example, we don’t feel
the need to talk about wheelchairs with the kids before Chris has a
problem walking.
L — Live your life
to the fullest! You have an opportunity to teach your children the importance
of grace through trials. Everyone faces hard times, and we have to learn
to move through them. It’s OK for us to have moments when we’re
sad, angry, upset or frustrated, but our kids need to see the opposite
more often — happiness, peace, enjoyment and calm. Magnify your life, not your ALS.
A — Attitudes are
contagious. Keep your own attitude healthy and positive. Fill your mind
with things that inspire you… music, nature, inspirational speakers,
sermons, Bible verses, work, children… whatever it may be. Where
the mind goes, the body follows. Let’s keep ours in a healthy
place!
N — Never lose
hope. If you want your kids to be hopeful, you have to show them how.
Being involved with other ALS families, through clinic and MDA events,
helps us keep hope. We’re really not alone in this battle, and
it’s healthy for our kids to see that.
C — Cues come from
our kids. They usually need small doses of information at a time. Our
6-year-old, Mason, asked why Daddy’s voice wasn’t getting
better since he’d been praying for this during the past two years.
We took the opportunity to say, “Some people with ALS can’t
speak at all. God has blessed Daddy because he’s still talking
so well.”
E — Experts are
available. Child psychologists, family counselors, books, church counselors
and other resources are meant to help. If your kids appear to be struggling,
accept help from an expert.
Chris and Reda Rice of Houston are co-chairs of MDA's ALS Division.
Back to top

ALS RESEARCH ROUNDUP
by Margaret Wahl
Embryonic Stem Cells Can Become Motor Neurons
Researchers at the University of Wisconsin-Madison announced online
on Jan. 30, in Nature Biotechnology, that they’ve developed
a chemical recipe to coax human embryonic stem cells to develop into
motor neurons, the muscle-controlling nerve cells that are lost in
ALS.
Xue-Jun Li and colleagues used two federally approved lines of stem
cells and exposed them to retinoic acid early and to several other
compounds later on.
Vassilis Koliatsos, an MDA-supported neuropathologist studying stem
cells at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, says the Wisconsin
researchers’ recipe works well in laboratory containers, but
that putting them into animals will likely “hold many surprises.”
Koliatsos said it’s unclear whether the new motor neurons would
survive in the face of an overwhelming degenerative process like that
seen in ALS. And, he notes, even if they did survive, getting them
to “talk to” muscle cells is another unmet challenge.
In ALS and other neurodegenerative diseases, Koliatsos says, every
neuron lost increases the chance that more neurons will be lost. “It’s
theoretically possible that we can put in the right number of cells
such that the neurodegenerative process can be delayed significantly,”
Koliatsos said, adding that not much else can yet be predicted.
Vitamin E, Military Service May Affect ALS Risk
Data collected from nearly a million people who participated in a
questionnaire-based study beginning in 1982 and ending in 1998 have
been used to determine what, if any, links exist between diet and
other lifestyle factors and causes of death.
When the data were analyzed with respect to ALS, investigators found
that taking vitamin E supplements may help prevent the disease, and
that service in the military may add to the risk of developing it.
Those who reported taking vitamin E supplements for at least 15 days
a month for 10 years or longer had 38 percent as great a chance of
developing ALS as those who never used vitamin E. For those taking
vitamin E for fewer than 10 years, the risk was 59 percent of the
risk for non-vitamin E users.
Albert Ascherio, an associate professor at the Harvard School of
Public Health and an author on both studies, cautions that no one
should use vitamin E on the basis of these results, which need confirmation.
The vitamin E study is in the January Annals of Neurology.
Data on military service were collected on approximately 400,000
men who filled out the questionnaire. All military service took place
before the Gulf War. Of the 280 ALS-related deaths recorded, 217 were
among the 281,874 men who had served in the military, implying an
ALS death rate of about 0.08 percent among the ex-military; and 63
were among the 126,414 who had never served, making an ALS death rate
of about 0.05 percent in that group.
Men who had served in the military had an ALS-related death rate
that was 1.53 times the rate for men who had never served.
In their Jan. 11 paper in Neurology, the authors say the results
suggest that exposures associated with military service but not unique
to the Gulf War should be investigated.
ALS Epidemiology Study Under Way
An MDA-funded study of ALS “epidemiology” (disease patterns)
is under way at Columbia University Medical Center in New York, headed
by Hiroshi Mitsumoto, co-director of the MDA/ALS Center at that institution.
The study will use interviews, questionnaires and blood samples to
investigate what, if any, relationship exists among factors in a person’s
residential, employment, medical, military and lifestyle history;
his or her DNA; and the development of ALS.
The researchers prefer residents of the New York area, at least for
the present. The study is scheduled to remain open until January 2007.
For more information, contact Ani Sara Thankachan in New York at (212) 305-4746.
Minocycline Trial Seeks Participants
There are openings for participants in a large, multicenter trial
of minocycline, an antibiotic in the tetracycline family, in ALS.
Minocycline appears to have anti-inflammatory and neuroprotective
properties and penetrates the central nervous system.
At sites across the United States, minocycline is being tested against
a placebo (inert substance) in 400 adults with ALS who have fairly
good respiratory function. Patients taking riluzole can participate
if the riluzole dose is stable.
For more information, contact Carolyn Doorish, project coordinator,
at (212) 305-2027 or cd2141@columbia.edu;
and see the clinical trials database at www.mda.org/research/ctrials.aspx.
New CoQ10 Study Opens in 19 Centers
A trial of high doses of coenzyme Q10 (coQ10) in 185 people with
ALS is now open for recruitment across the United States. Investigators
will compare coQ10 with a placebo (inactive substance) to see whether
it slows the course of the disease.
CoQ10 is a natural compound that acts inside the mitochondria, the
“powerhouses” of the cell. It supports the cell’s
energy metabolism and helps to neutralize free radicals, molecules
that carry an electrical charge and can damage other cellular components.
The compound has been found to be safe and relatively well tolerated
in people with ALS, even when taken at high doses.
Adults with ALS who aren’t ventilator-dependent or who use
part-time noninvasive ventilation, have had ALS for less than five
years, and who meet other study criteria, are eligible.
For information, contact Alexandra Barsdorf, clinical coordinator,
at Columbia University Medical Center in New York, at (212)
342-3026 or aib2104@columbia.edu;
and see the clinical trials database at www.mda.org/research/ctrials.aspx.
Back to top
Travel Tips From People on the Go
by Kathy Wechsler
Retired nurse Jan Sluiter, of Cedar Falls, Iowa, received a diagnosis
of ALS in 1988 and uses a power wheelchair. Sluiter, 55, and her husband,
Jim, travel twice a year by van to Ontario, Canada, to see family. They’ve
also flown to the Bahamas, Hawaii, Arizona, Florida and Washington and
don’t plan to slow down.
 |
|
Jan and Jim Sluiter enjoy Hanauma Bay
on the island of Oahu, Hawaii, in November 2003. Jan Sluiter
relaxes in a rented beach wheelchair.
|
Here’s some advice from Sluiter that’s helped make her
travels more enjoyable:
- Always travel with your living will, for emergencies.
- Never book flights online or through a travel agency. Sluiter reserves
through the airline’s headquarters (usually Northwest Airlines)
to ensure they understand her needs. Before the flight, she calls
the airline to confirm she’s coming.
- Choose flights that use jetways to avoid steps to the airplane.
If there won’t be a jetway, Sluiter ensures there will be a
forklift with a platform and a forklift operator to raise her in the
chair up to the plane door.
- Arrange for an aisle seat near the front. If Sluiter can’t
get a seat toward the front, airline employees are trained to take
her down the aisle in a straightback wheelchair or aisle chair.
- Never take your power chair when traveling by air, to avoid damaging
it. Sluiter checks her manual wheelchair at the gate instead of curbside
or sending it through with the luggage. Somebody will bring her chair
right to the front of the plane when it’s time to exit the aircraft.
- Allow at least an hour between connecting flights for gate changes.
Wheelchair users are the last passengers off the plane.
- Call ahead to the rental car company to make sure the shuttle is
wheelchair accessible. (Hertz has accessible shuttles.)
- Always reserve the hotel room in advance. Sluiter specifies her
exact requirements. Of course, the bathroom has to be large enough
and have a raised toilet seat and grab bars, but she also spells out
that she wants a roll-in shower. She’s been happy with the Sheraton,
Marriott, Holiday Inn Express, AmeriHost, AmericInn and Homestead
Suites. Before leaving home, she calls again to double-check that
her needs will be met.
Steve and Helene Nichols of Clifton, Va., drive all over the East Coast,
and they’ve cruised Alaska, Bermuda, Russia, some Caribbean islands,
the Panama Canal and the Hudson River. A retired computer network specialist,
Steve, 54, has had ALS for 10 years and uses a power chair that he operates
with a knee switch. He also has a tracheostomy and a feeding tube and
uses a communication system to speak. Steve’s the 2005 MDA Personal
Achievement Award recipient for the state of Virginia.
 |
|
Steve and Helene Nichols set sail for
Bermuda from New York City in August 2004.
|
Here are some helpful travel tips from Steve and Helene:
- Organization’s the key. Helene makes supply lists for all
equipment needed for Steve’s care. The lists include everything
from portable lifts to Steve’s eye-tracking communication device.
- Once the Nicholses are on a ship, all their supplies are easily
available. There’s no need to haul them around because the hotel
travels with them.
- Do your homework. The couple ask for specific accommodations such
as a roll-in shower. Larger ships, they say, tend to be more accessible,
with larger cabins and larger bathrooms, wheelchair-accessible entertainment
and medical facilities. Steve and Helene ensure the ship docks in
a port because transport boats to the ship are generally too small
for the power chair. They’ve found Holland America and Royal
Caribbean to be very accessible.
- Call ahead and make sure that there are vans with wheelchair tie-downs
for any land travel.
- Don’t go on trips in the winter because of the risk of exposure
to the flu.
- Get some help. A friend often travels with them, so that if Helene
wants to do her own thing, their friend makes sure Steve is safe.
- When traveling in the United States, always carry the phone number
of your MDA clinic doctor. When driving, the Nicholses carry a list
of dealers that can help with their accessible van.
- Carry travel insurance at all times. The Nicholses are always prepared
to evacuate the ship by medical transport and know ahead of time how
to get off the ship in a medical emergency; travel insurance would
help pay for it. The couple also carries extra health insurance forms.
- Don’t put it off. The Nicholses wish that they’d flown
to Australia and other faraway destinations while Steve had greater
mobility. They advise you to go to the distant places before your
needs expand.
You can e-mail Jan Sluiter at jjsluiter@cfu.net and Steve and Helene Nichols at slohcinjs@hotmail.com.
For more information on airport security, see “Leaving
on a Jet Plane…,” in MDA’s magazine Quest, March/April
2003. To find out more about airplane travel in general, see “How
to Fly Through the Air With the Greatest of Ease,” in Quest,
April 2000. Quest’s regular column “To Boldly Go”
explores accessible travel destinations.
Face-off Draws Fire
I enjoyed reading the two opposing positions on the multidrug
trials (“Face-off on Multidrug
Trials,” January) and felt compelled to address a few
of the comments made by Jeremy Shefner (director of the MDA/ALS
center in Syracuse, N.Y.).
I submit that a clinical trial that conforms with medically and
scientifically accepted practices has merit. Even if the trial
fails, it provides data to expand the knowledge base for understanding
motor neuron diseases.
“Patients want to know what works” as an argument
to diminish the value of the trials is not valid. I would be delighted
to take a concoction if it meant I could walk again.
Alternatively, “you don’t just combine them”
is correct unless the experimenter has a valid hypothesis for
selecting the components. Each ingredient has a perfectly good
reason for inclusion in the “cocktail.” Indeed, Jeffrey
Rosenfeld (director of the MDA/ALS center in Charolette, N.C.)
states his purpose is to determine the safety and feasibility
of simply taking the pills and not the efficacy. I would much
prefer Shefner to offer constructive criticism that would strengthen
the trials instead of dismissing them out of hand.
Finally, I am grateful that Dr. Rosenfeld is being proactive
and treating the symptoms of motor neuron disease. The alternative
is a life without hope.
Angelo Sciulli
Lancaster, S.C. |
Denise Figlewicz, Ph.D.: Turning the ALS Kaleidoscope
by Margaret Wahl
Denise Figlewicz, an associate professor and research scientist in
the Department of Neurology at the University of Michigan, says she’s
wanted to be in science ever since she was a child, growing up in
Chicago. One of four children, and an identical twin, Figlewicz learned
the chemical formulas for things like water and sugar from her pharmacist
mother, who taught her that “chemistry was just a language.”
She learned about astronomy, geology and biology from her engineer
father, who frequently told his children, “Open your peepers
and look at the world.”
Denise and her twin sister Dianne, now a neuroscientist at the Veterans
Affairs Medical Center and University of Washington in Seattle, graduated
from high school at 15 and entered Loyola University, from which they
both graduated at 19.
 |
|
Neuroscientist Denise Figlewicz
|
Denise went on to complete her doctoral degree in biochemistry at
Loyola and then to study at the National Institutes of Health and
National Naval Medical Research Institute, both in Bethesda, Md.
Opportunity Knocks
In 1984, Figlewicz was a young biochemist at Harvard, studying myelination,
the process by which an insulating sheath is wrapped around nerve
fibers.
There, she met neurologist Robert Brown, who told her of an opportunity
in Switzerland involving the study of motor neurons, the nerve cells
in the spinal cord and brain that control muscle activity and that
are mysteriously lost in ALS.
 |
|
Denise Figlewicz and her twin sister, neuroscientist Diane Figlewicz Lattemann. "You wouldn't believe how many things are programmed genetically," Denise says.
|
“I thought, ‘This is a chance to go live in Europe,’”
Figlewicz remembers. “No one will offer this again.” It
meant adjusting her goals a little, but it was still neuroscience,
and it intrigued her. “So I switched to motor neuron diseases,”
she says, “and I’ve stayed in that field ever since.”
Once in Lausanne, Figlewicz began tackling the wobbler mouse, a model
of motor neuron disease commonly used in the 1980s. Figlewicz’s
role was to compare the proteins in spinal cords of the wobbler mice
with proteins from non-wobbler spinal cords. It was rough going.
“These mice went downhill very quickly,” she says. “By
the time you noticed the symptoms and took the spinal cord out for
study, the motor neurons were gone. I thought, ‘I’m wasting
my time. This mouse has a mutant gene that’s causing this trait.
If we could find the gene, we’d have the answer.’”
But molecular genetics was a young science, opportunities to study
mouse genes were scarce, and in 1987, Figlewicz returned home to Harvard.
A Payoff
The timing was fortuitous. Brown was getting together with other
investigators to form what would later be known as the Familial ALS
Consortium, to identify an ALS-causing gene in patients.
Teepu Siddique and Allen Roses, both then at Duke University, and
Guy Rouleau at Montreal General Hospital, were part of the new, MDA-supported
project. “MDA paid for us to meet once or twice a year and talk
about our work,” Figlewicz recalls. “Everybody else said
this was a long shot, but MDA said, ‘If you get together and
share your results, we’ll fund you.’”
Mutations in the SOD1 (superoxide dismutase 1) gene were already
under suspicion, because in some of the families in which the disease
appeared to be inherited (familial), all the affected members had
unusual DNA sequences in the same area of chromosome 21 — SOD1’s
neighborhood.
The long shot paid off. In 1993, the FALS Consortium scientists published
a paper showing unequivocally that mutations in the SOD1 gene could
cause a familial form of ALS.
The following year, MDA grantee Mark Gurney at Northwestern University
developed an animal model of ALS by breeding mice with an SOD1 mutation
known as G93A, a model used by the majority of ALS researchers today.
Beyond SOD1
But Figlewicz speculated that, even in those few families where the
disease was clearly caused by mutated SOD1, there had to be other
factors involved.
“In a given family where the mutation turned out to be SOD1,
we still saw tremendous variation in the age of onset and in the nature
and course of the disease. You could have two closely related people
with the exact same mutation, and the clinical phenotype [observable
traits] could be different.”
Figlewicz thought about differences in environmental exposures, and
still does. But she also felt certain there were differences in genes
besides SOD1 that modified the illness. Finding them might, she reasoned,
allow for more accurate predictions of risk in ALS patients’
relatives. Moreover, it could open the door to understanding more
biochemical factors that can enhance or minimize the death of motor
neurons.
Figlewicz’s group has MDA funding to test the effects of the
G93A mutation in SOD1 in up to six strains of mice and has started
with three.
So far, she’s found that the severity of the SOD1-caused ALS
is “very different” depending on the mouse genetic background
(strain), even when the mice live in the same environment.
“You wouldn’t believe how many things are programmed
genetically,” she says, joking that she’s a “genetic
clone” herself and relating tales of how she and Dianne not
only have pursued similar careers, but share the same preferences
in art, music, movies and nail polish, and buy people the same Christmas
presents.
“Science is like a kaleidoscope,” she says. “There
are facts and studies that you’ve looked at and made a mental
note of, and then you turn the kaleidoscope a little and you see a
new picture emerge.”
ALS Online

Meals for
Easy Swallowing, no longer in print,
is now available in its entirety on
the MDA Web site. The 125-page book
comprises a collection of recipes for
foods for people who have swallowing
difficulties. The easy-access, online
version provides recipes for meats and
other protein-containing foods, fruits
or fruit drinks, vegetables, and breads,
as well as suggestions on food preparation
and service.
Selections of beverages, desserts and sauces also are provided.
The online guide also contains swallowing tips and techniques.
The book was published by the MDA/ALS center at Baylor College
of Medicine in Houston. |
Back to top
A Qualified Income Trust: Keep Your Medicaid Eligibility
by Kathy Weschler
One of the principal responsibilities of Medicaid is to pay for nursing
home care for those who qualify for this federal health care assistance
program.
If you’re going into a nursing home and your state disqualifies
you from receiving benefits because your income exceeds the Medicaid
limit, you may feel as if you’re swimming against a strong current:
You can’t qualify for nursing home Medicaid benefits because
your monthly income exceeds the income cap, but you don’t receive
enough monthly income to pay for your nursing home without help from
Medicaid. What to do?
Used in states that have income caps on those who qualify for Medicaid
benefits for institutionalized care, the Qualified Income Trust (QIT, also known as a Miller Trust) is a legal way around the
income limit, says K. Gabriel Heiser, an elder-law attorney in Boulder,
Colo.
WHAT’S A QIT?
A QIT is an account in which you deposit enough of your income —
earned, pension, Social Security, etc. — to reduce your qualifying
income for Medicaid coverage of your nursing home care. In most states,
the income cap is $1,737 per month, or three times the current Supplemental
Security Income [SSI] benefit.
Placing funds into a QIT lets you qualify for Medicaid eligibility
for benefits such as long-term care programs, according to a Florida
Department of Children & Families (FDCF) official. For other restrictions
on the QIT, see “Medicaid and Your Money.”
When creating a QIT, make sure you’re dealing with someone
experienced in the Medicaid arena, such as an elder-law attorney who’s
familiar with QIT accounts and how they work, advises Charles Robinson,
an elder-law attorney in Clearwater, Fla. To find such an expert in
your area, visit the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys Web site
at www.naela.org.
Both Heiser and Robinson recommend appointing a QIT trustee; one
isn’t required but is helpful.
It’s important to note that you don’t set up a QIT in
advance, but rather in the first month that you’re in the nursing
home and seeking Medicaid benefits, Heiser says. Your attorney will
help you set up a special bank account (usually a checking account)
to be used specifically for the QIT.
The account then pays you a monthly personal needs allowance (which
varies from state to state; e.g., it’s $35 in Florida and $50
in Colorado).
If you’re married, the QIT may also pay your spouse living
at home an income allowance, if his or her income doesn’t meet
your state’s allowance level.
The amount remaining in the QIT after the two allowances are paid,
along with your Medicaid qualifying income, is paid to the nursing
home. Medicaid then covers the difference between what you’ve
paid and the nursing home’s actual charges. The QIT’s
resources and your income will then be entirely exhausted.
When you die, the state receives all money remaining in the trust
up to the amount that Medicaid has paid on your behalf.
QIT Example: |
$ 1,900 |
monthly income |
$ 6,000 |
nursing home cost |
$-1,737 |
income cap |
$-1,737 |
paid by client |
$ 163 |
to QIT |
$ 4,263 |
|
$ -50 |
personal needs allowance |
$ - 113 |
paid by QIT |
$ 113 |
|
$ 4,150 |
paid by Medicaid |
A SIMPLE EXAMPLE
“Bob,” who’s 41 and lives in Colorado, received
a diagnosis of ALS three years ago and is now looking for a good long-term
care facility in the area.
Bob’s assets are below $2,000, but he isn’t eligible
to receive Medicaid benefits because his monthly income, from Social
Security benefits and his pension, is $1,900, which is $163 over the
income limit of $1,737. Without help from Medicaid, there’s
no way he can pay the $6,000 monthly bill from the nursing home.
That’s where the QIT comes in. Because he wants his Medicaid
benefits to start in February when he moves into the facility, Bob
and his sister Sue visit Richard Jones, a local elder-law attorney
in February. Sue is named Bob’s trustee, and Jones establishes
a separate bank account in her name for the QIT.
Each month, Bob’s excess income ($163) is transferred to the
QIT, and Bob pays the nursing home $1,737. Then, Bob’s monthly
personal needs allowance of $50 is paid out of the QIT by Sue. Sue
then pays the nursing home the remaining $113 and the trust balance
goes to zero. Medicaid pays the facility the balance of $4,150.
QIT BENEFITS OUTSIDE A NURSING HOME
Can you use a QIT to qualify for Medicaid benefits if you’re not going into a nursing home? The answer varies from state to state.
Some states, such as Florida, have nursing home diversion Medicaid
waiver programs, which allow for care at home. Depending on the state,
Medicaid might pay for an assisted living facility. To use a QIT,
you need to be going into a long-term care program, not just looking
for Medicaid assistance with prescriptions or physician visits.
The contents of this article are intended to be general information
and shouldn’t be construed as legal, tax or financial advice.
Medicaid and Your Money
Medicaid is a federal program, but it’s administered by
the individual states. That means the guidelines and regulations
on QIT and other Medicaid programs vary from state to state.
To find out whether you’re eligible for Medicaid assistance,
check with the Medicaid office in your state. Each state establishes
its own eligibility requirements based on three criteria: your
care needs, your income and your assets.
Earned wages, Social Security, disability insurance, retirement,
pension and alimony all count toward the income cap for Medicaid
eligibility.
There’s also an asset limit imposed on Medicaid recipients:
$2,000 for an individual seeking institutional care and $3,000
if both spouses need institutional care. Assets consist of bank
accounts, brokerage accounts, stocks and bonds, loans, annuities,
and any resource of value owned jointly by you and your spouse.
In most states you’re allowed to retain one home and one
vehicle outside the asset limit, but things like your boat and
your private airplane count against you.
Once you’re eligible for Medicaid, most states also cover
physician, psychologist, rehabilitation, chiropractic, dental,
laboratory and X-ray services, hospital visits, prescription
drugs and prosthetic devices.
To learn the rules of your state’s Medicaid program,
visit www.cms.hhs.gov/medicaid/statemap.asp,
and click on your state; and call your Medicaid agency. You
also can call Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services at (877) 267-2323.
|
Back to top
Assistive Technology Is Still Emerging
by Tara Wood
Like those of other fields of technology, followers of the assistive
technology industry can now anticipate annual unveilings of new products.
Several assistive items that can have an impact on quality of life
were launched at recent, turn-of-the-year conferences and trade shows
and will be of interest to people with ALS:
TrackerPro by Madentec.
This is the latest, smallest model of a head-tracking device that enables
people who can’t move their hands to access a computer with slight
head movements. The TrackerPro is plug-and-play (no software needed),
plugs into a USB port, and the golf-ball size camera can be easily mounted
on laptops or monitors. $995. www.madentec.com or (877) 623-3682.
Kelvin, a voice-activated thermostat
by Independent Living Aids. This fully programmable
thermostat can be preset for functions like raising or lowering the
temperature at a given time during the day. It can be operated by touching
buttons, or once it’s programmed, users can talk to the thermostat
to raise or lower the temperature. Professional installation is recommended.
$129. www.independentliving.com or (800) 537-2118.
Cyrano Communicator by OneWrite.
Cyrano is a hand-held, portable, AAC (augmentative and alternative communication)
device. Its software is designed to enable speech-impaired individuals
to communicate through a series of customizable images, text and sounds.
$1,199. www.cyranocommunicator.com or (800) 268-6070.
WiVik (Version 3) by Prentke Romich.
This on-screen keyboard provides access to any application in the latest
Windows operating systems. Improvements include the availability of
access by switch-based scanning, plus WordQ word prediction and abbreviation
expansion. $350. www.prentrom.com or (800)262-1933.
Freedom Box and Freedom Box System Access
by Serotek. Freedom Box is an Internet access device
that allows users to operate computers and navigate the Web by voice
command. The Freedom Box System Access is a program that makes any Windows
XP or 2000 system accessible via voice command. It’s free for
the home system of any person with a FreedomBox Network account ($9.95
per month), and can become portable when used in conjunction with FreedomBox
devices like the PassKey ($99). www.freedombox.info or (866) 202-0520.
My Voice ID by Support Systems Product
Development. This device allows a person to record audio
medical information on a pager-sized recorder that can be easily accessible
to emergency response personnel at the push of a button. It has a 60-
to 80-word capacity and includes a medical card for printed health background
information and emergency contact data. It can be clipped onto a belt,
handbag or backpack for added visibility. $40. www.myvoiceid.org or (866) 667-5768.
 |
|
My Voice ID attached to a person's belt.
|
Say-it SAM Tablet Systems by Words+.
A new, tablet-style communication system features the Say-it! SAM communication
software. The Tablet SM1 has scanning, an 8.4-inch touchscreen display,
and multiple input modes, and weighs 3.9 pounds. Both the regular and
the Medicare-approved “dedicated” model are $6,675. www.words-plus.com or (800) 869-8521.
MightyMo and MiniMo by DynaVox.
These communication devices offer several preprogrammed, professionally
recorded page sets, and capacity to hold more than 100 minutes of additional
digitized speech and sound. Each has dedicated versions that meet Medicare
or Medicaid guidelines. MightyMo is $2,795, MiniMo is $2,495. www.dynavoxtech.com or (800) 344-2778.
Return
to Issues Index |